The Conversation
08 Oct 2019, 01:47 GMT+10
A report from The Australia Institute rejects government claims new dams are not being built, saying at least 20 to 30 large private dams have been constructed in the Murray-Darling basin in recent years.
While information on the number of private dams and the cost of their taxpayer subsidy is limited, the report says "it appears that just two of these dams cost taxpayers nearly $30 million".
"Over $200 million was spent on dam-related projects [in the Murray-Darling Basin] according to official data, although not all of this will have been specifically on dams," it says,
Maryanne Slattery, senior water researcher at the institute, said politicians don't want to talk about these dams because "they do nothing for drought-stricken communities, the health of the river or struggling farmers".
"These dams have been built on private land and are for the exclusive use of corporate agribusiness, such as Webster Limited," she said.
"Politicians are reluctant to talk about why millions of taxpayer dollars have been spent subsidising dams that make the problems of the Murray Darling Basin worse".
Water Minister David Littleproud has repeatedly berated the states for not building new dams. He said recently that of the 20 dams completed since 2003, 16 were in Tasmania.
"If NSW, Queensland and Victoria don't start building dams, their water storage capacity will fall by more than 30% by 2030," he said. "We put $1.3 billion on the table in through the national water infrastructure development fund in 2015 and have still had to drag most states kicking and screaming to build new dams."
The report says new public dams would require public consultation, including with stakeholders who had environmental and economic concerns.
But private dams involved "minimal public consultation and can be approved and constructed based on environmental assessments commissioned from private consultants by dam proponents".
The report looked at three dams in detail, on properties in the Murrumbidgee Valley owned by Webster Ltd - Glenmea, Bringagee and Kooba Station. The dams were funded out of the federal government's $4 billion water efficiency program.
The report argues such dams are not the best way to save water. It points to the department of agriculture and water resources saying new dams can save water where they replace shallower ones (which have more evaporation), or where they collect recycled irrigation water.
"However, none of the three case-study dams in this report save water in this way. They are new dams, not replacing smaller, shallower dams. Water stored behind their approximately eight metre high walls would otherwise be stored in public headwater dams around 100 metres deep."
These dams are designed to divert normal irrigation water and "supplementary water" - not to simply recycle irrigation water, the report says. Thus "they increase both evaporation and irrigation water use".
Supplementary water is water that is surplus to consumptive needs. It is important environmentally and to downstream users, historically making up almost all the water flowing from the Murrumbidgee into the Murray, the report says.
"With major dams now targeting this water, the Murrumbidgee could be disconnected from the Murray in most years. This has implications for all NSW Basin water users, who are already grappling with how to meet downstream obligations within the Murray's constraints and with no water coming down the Darling."
The report says a Canadian pension fund had just been reported as "swooping" on Webster, "with specific mention of a property with one of these new dams".
"The new dams that Australian taxpayers helped build appear to be highly valued by international investors," the report says.
Author: Michelle Grattan - Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra
Get a daily dose of Vancouver Star news through our daily email, its complimentary and keeps you fully up to date with world and business news as well.
Publish news of your business, community or sports group, personnel appointments, major event and more by submitting a news release to Vancouver Star.
More InformationWASHINGTON, D.C.: This week, U.S. Supreme Court justices seemed open to letting fuel companies challenge California's strict vehicle...
WASHINGTON, D.C.: The Trump administration announced this week that it will create a fast-track approval process for energy and mining...
JERUSALEM - More than 80 ambassadors and heads of mission from across the world were addressed by Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu...
WASHINGTON, D.C.: U.S. lawmakers are turning up the heat on China's biggest telecom firms, issuing subpoenas to compel their cooperation...
BRUSSELS, Belgium: European pharmaceutical companies are pushing for higher drug prices across the EU, warning that current pricing...
WASHINGTON, D.C.: A nuclear power plant in Michigan is hoping to become the first in the U.S. to restart after being permanently shut...
WASHINGTON, D.C.: The United States and India are advancing talks on a wide-ranging trade agreement that would cover 19 key areas,...
TOKYO, Japan: Toyota's overseas sales surged to a new March record, driven largely by a rush of North American buyers ahead of newly...
NEW YORK, New York - Uncertainty about trade negotiations between the United States and China kept investors and traders on edge Monday...
WASHINGTON, D.C.: Sales of new single-family homes in the U.S. rose more than expected in March as buyers rushed to take advantage...
SHANGHAI, China: BMW is set to incorporate artificial intelligence from Chinese startup DeepSeek into its upcoming vehicle models in...
Hong Kong: Cathay Pacific Airways is preparing for a slowdown in air cargo traffic between China and the United States as new trade...